Carolyn Apartments

108–218 Carolyn Ln, Eureka, IL · 18-Unit Multifamily

Property Overview

Carolyn Apartments is a three-building multifamily asset located in Eureka, Illinois. The property consists of three solid brick apartment buildings totaling 18 units and offers stable in-place cash flow with significant recent capital improvements. Ownership completed extensive renovations between 2017–2025, including unit interior updates, roofing replacements, boiler replacements, flooring upgrades, paint and trim improvements, and selective garage additions. The asset is positioned in a low-supply Central Illinois rental market with continued upside through rent growth.

Property Highlights

  • 18-unit low-rise walk-up multifamily asset
  • Three solid brick buildings
  • Entirely 2-bedroom unit mix
  • Majority of units renovated or updated
  • Interior upgrades include:
  • New flooring
  • Paint and trim improvements
  • Full and partial remodels
  • Additional garage income on select units
  • Major capital improvements completed:
  • Building 108: Boiler (2015), Roof (2016)
  • Building 200: Roof (2017), Boiler (2024)
  • Building 218: Roof (2017), Boiler (2023)
  • Strong operational profile with limited deferred maintenance
  • Located in a low-supply rental market with limited new multifamily construction

Key Details

  • Address108–218 Carolyn Ln, Eureka, IL
  • Total Units18
  • Unit MixAll 2 Bedroom Units
  • Year Built1965
  • List Price$1,175,000
  • Price Per Unit$65,278
  • Current Cap Rate8.02%
  • Potential Cap Rate12.55%
  • Current Average Rent~$746/unit
  • Potential Average Rent$1,000/unit
  • MarketEureka, Illinois (Central Illinois / Peoria MSA region)
Inspired By This Deal?

Could yours be the next one we close?

Whether you're thinking about selling, repositioning, or executing a 1031 exchange — start with a real conversation. We'll listen first and give you actual numbers, not just a pitch.